See What Our Customers Have to Say

We’re always very proud of the stunning jewelry our customers have left with – but don’t just take our word for it. See below for reviews!

Real People, Real Reviews Contact Us

Filter by Tags

D.C. | Upper Arlington, OH

Absolutely superb technical craftsmanship. The CAD enabled design process allows for complexity and precision that can’t be matched at any conventional jeweler. But it’s Scott’s gift for design and passion for perfection that deliver the ‘wow’ results. It was an absolute pleasure to work with someone so skilled and dedicated to their craft. It was truly a special experience to create a distinctively unique piece – it couldn’t have happened anywhere else!

J.B. | Columbus, OH

We had a custom engagement ring designed and could not have been more pleased with the process and the end result. Scott and his team went above and beyond what we expected. I highly recommend working with them. Their integrity and personal commitment to people and relationships speaks volumes in todays world, where those qualities are so hard to find. Thank you so much for making our dream a reality.

B.R. | Dublin, OH

We were referred to Scott’s by a friend who recently spent months searching for the right ring/right jeweler. We cannot say enough good things about Scott and his family. We had a detailed consultation which helped Scott determine what I really wanted in a ring since I was a little unsure. Scott has a gift! After his evaluation he identified my preference for a white diamond. We ended up getting a super high quality ring for a fantastic price. We enjoyed the process and getting to know the family. Can’t wait to go back to pick out the wedding bands!

G.M. | Dublin, OH

During my two recent visits to Scott’s Custom Jewelers I was most impressed with the friendly and personable environment. Equally important was the professional knowledge, experience, and service provided by both Scott and Beth. On each occasion, the first with assistance from Beth, and the second with assistance from Scott, I was able to find that perfect jewelry item I was looking for. I highly recommend Scott’s Custom Jewelers to those looking for that special item and for those looking for Custom Design assistance.

K.H. | Tacoma, WA

My fiancé Kayla and I are so grateful to have worked with Scott’s Custom Jewelers for our engagement rings! We live across the country but knew about Scott’s from previously living in Ohio and they came highly recommended from friends and family. We wanted only the best to help us design our dream rings and that’s exactly what they did! Scott and Beth are so welcoming and made the process as smooth as can be! They were prompt with answering questions through email and our phone conversations and worked with us to schedule the perfect time for an in person consultation for when we would be in town! When we came to their office to design our rings they were very patient with us both and had plenty of options waiting for us to mix and match. They accommodated our every request and they delivered our rings to us across the country worry free and they were everything we were hoping for and more! We both get so many compliments on the cut and settings of our rings. You cannot go wrong with Scott’s Custom Jewelers, it’s local, sustainable, family owned, and they will move mountains to make sure they create the perfect engagement ring for you! Thanks Scott and Beth!!

M.T. | Dublin, OH

We stopped in because we wanted custom rings. Scott’s was exactly what we wanted and needed. After giving a few guidelines of what we wanted; (vintage; hammered), they helped us design exactly what we wanted within our price range. Scott sent me images of a work in progress and never grew tired of my adaptations. You can see the results are amazing and perfect for us. The process couldn’t have been easier and is unique to us! We can’t wait for those rings to be on our fingers May 22nd! Thank you Scott and Beth❣️

M.P. | Columbus, OH

I came to Scott’s with the request of making a replica of my grandmas ring as a wedding ring for myself. I had previously spoken with other jewelers about the request and they all said they could or would damage the original ring in the process of making a replication. This was obviously not an option for me, so I was very elated to hear that Scott could make a copy while keeping the original safe and in-tact. He not only made a perfect replica, but made the frame of the copy even sturdier than the original design without changing the look. I was more than satisfied with the level of care and attention put into the pieces I had crafted at Scott’s Custom Jewelers. After my ring was finished we still hadn’t found an option we liked for my husband’s ring, and realized that we both wanted these symbols of our marriage to be unique to us. …..Needless to say we chose to have his ring made at Scott’s as well. Though this one was a little last minute, they were still able to make it in less time than expected, leaving us with a finished product that was exactly what we asked for. If you are looking for custom wedding sets, or simply to have a unique piece commissioned for a special someone- do not hesitate to contact Scott’s Custom Jewelry. Why have average when you can have awesome? It’s really NOT as much as you think! (I was genuinely surprised at this)

E.C. | Columbus, OH

I had never had any custom jewelry made before but I purchased a ring that was fairly ugly but had a really pretty large opal in it. I felt that the opal would be much better as a pendant than a ring. Scott’s Custom Jewelers did an awesome job of designing a pendant that brought out the great qualities of the stone. I liked the job so much that I decided to have them design a new setting for a star sapphire ring that was my late husband’s.

M.M. | Hilliard, OH

My family had a relationship with a different jeweler for nearly 40 years. So anytime an anniversary, birthday, or special event came up – I had a cheat code. COVID unfortunately led that company to close the doors. I was honestly considering the long game, and a 10-year plan to convince my wife that jewelry was all a scam, a waste of money, or whatever other option I thought she may buy (spoiler: she wouldn’t have gone for any of those)… All because I was terrified to work with an unknown jeweler. 10 Year anniversary was approaching and my delay tactics had lost effectiveness. I did some research, landed on Scott’s Custom Jewelers, and made my first visit about a month ago. I was blown away with the professionalism, relatability, and knowledge of the team. I ended up buying my wife a pair of earrings that she loves and I felt completely at peace with the process. As long as Scott’s keeps the doors open – we have our go-to jeweler and my wife’s never been happier with the gifts that sit out on the horizon. Loved this experience!

Ready to make something beautiful at Scott’s?

We start every design with a conversation, pictures and a pencil. It’s an easy and fun way to find out what you like, what you want, and how much it will cost.

Not sure what you want? No sweat – we’ve got literally thousands of ideas we can show you!

Stop in and let’s create something beautiful together!

– We’ll Help You Design Your Dream –

Get in Touch