See What Our Customers Have to Say

We’re always very proud of the stunning jewelry our customers have left with – but don’t just take our word for it. See below for reviews!

Real People, Real Reviews Contact Us

Filter by Tags

E.S. | Columbus, OH

My husband & I purchased our wedding bands from here and we could not be more than pleased with the result. Our wedding bands came out so unique and specific. We have one of kind rings and we continue to receive so many compliments on them. It was so easy to work with Scott’s Jewelers Family. They listened to all our requests and provided their honest professional opinion which made it that much more of a fun collaborative experience. If you want beautiful one of kind rings go to Scott’s Jewelers!

P.s. I also have gone here to get jewelry fixed and they have done an amazing job with that. The only jeweler I trust to fix any jewelry.

L.M. | Columbus, OH

We were looking for a jeweler who could use all the diamonds we had accumulated from our family and recreate my original wedding ring. What we got was even better than we had hoped for! Scott designed a stunning wedding ring incorporating all of our family’s gems. I couldn’t be more pleased! I hope he can add a photo of his beautiful creation to this review for me. His team (all family) also did a number of repairs on our other rings that were also very good. From the time we came in for the first time to when we completed our business, the whole Scott’s Custom Jewelers team made us feel like family. I would highly recommend them for any of your jewelry needs. We are so happy!

J.C. | Dublin, OH

I went to Scott’s to have a custom wedding band guard created. When I was originally engaged my husband got me a beautiful Diamond wedding set that I loved. However I secretly always wanted an emerald and recently found my “dream ring”. In order to incorporate my original wedding set, Scott’s used almost all the diamonds to create a guard for my new emerald. It is such a beautiful piece that compliments and enhances my new emerald perfectly and I constantly have people stopping me to mention how much they love the entire set. I also still have the original solitaire Diamond from my engagement ring that I have told my husband he could use to custom create me another piece of jewelry haha! Scott’s has excellent customer service, everyone is very friendly and personable. The turnaround on my design was relatively quick and communication was consistent throughout the process. Would highly recommend for anyone looking to redesign something or create something new!

M.M. | Columbus, OH

Every time I wear the ring Scott’s created for me, I catch myself staring at it. I LOVE it – it’s exactly what I wanted. The team at Scott’s is kind, professional, skilled and accommodating. Thanks to their creativity and expertise, the heirloom items I brought to them were given new life and transformed into modern, tasteful designs. I was not only impressed with the end result, but I also truly appreciated their respect for my family heirlooms. The Scott’s Team genuinely cared about the people, history and relationships those items signified to me. Because of the care and attention with which the Scott’s Team handled my projects, I now have gorgeous new jewelry that beautifully honors my loved ones and makes me smile every day.

K.M. | Columbus, OH

I could not say enough about my experience with Scott’s. I came to them with a design for a wedding ring for my girlfriend, not even knowing if it was possible, and worked with me to create a ring better then I ever imagined. And as of today my girlfriend is no longer my Girlfriend but my Fiancé. Thank you so much!

D.C. | Upper Arlington, OH

Absolutely superb technical craftsmanship. The CAD enabled design process allows for complexity and precision that can’t be matched at any conventional jeweler. But it’s Scott’s gift for design and passion for perfection that deliver the ‘wow’ results. It was an absolute pleasure to work with someone so skilled and dedicated to their craft. It was truly a special experience to create a distinctively unique piece – it couldn’t have happened anywhere else!

J.B. | Columbus, OH

We had a custom engagement ring designed and could not have been more pleased with the process and the end result. Scott and his team went above and beyond what we expected. I highly recommend working with them. Their integrity and personal commitment to people and relationships speaks volumes in todays world, where those qualities are so hard to find. Thank you so much for making our dream a reality.

B.R. | Dublin, OH

We were referred to Scott’s by a friend who recently spent months searching for the right ring/right jeweler. We cannot say enough good things about Scott and his family. We had a detailed consultation which helped Scott determine what I really wanted in a ring since I was a little unsure. Scott has a gift! After his evaluation he identified my preference for a white diamond. We ended up getting a super high quality ring for a fantastic price. We enjoyed the process and getting to know the family. Can’t wait to go back to pick out the wedding bands!

G.M. | Dublin, OH

During my two recent visits to Scott’s Custom Jewelers I was most impressed with the friendly and personable environment. Equally important was the professional knowledge, experience, and service provided by both Scott and Beth. On each occasion, the first with assistance from Beth, and the second with assistance from Scott, I was able to find that perfect jewelry item I was looking for. I highly recommend Scott’s Custom Jewelers to those looking for that special item and for those looking for Custom Design assistance.

Ready to make something beautiful at Scott’s?

We start every design with a conversation, pictures and a pencil. It’s an easy and fun way to find out what you like, what you want, and how much it will cost.

Not sure what you want? No sweat – we’ve got literally thousands of ideas we can show you!

Stop in and let’s create something beautiful together!

– We’ll Help You Design Your Dream –

Get in Touch